When it comes to on-demand printing for your eCommerce business, Printify and Customcat are two popular platforms to consider.
Both Printify and Customcat offer different benefits and drawbacks, so it’s important to weigh the pros and cons to find the best fit for your needs.
In this article, we will compare Printify and Customcat in terms of profitability, quality, print coverage, product selection, and sales channel integrations.
Whether you’re a new entrepreneur starting an eCommerce store or an experienced seller looking to expand your product offerings, this comparison will provide you with the information you need to make an informed decision.
Let’s dive into the details.
Printify vs CustomCat – Quality
When it comes to the quality of print-on-demand products, independent reviewers have consistently ranked Printify above Customcat.
Printify’s products have garnered positive feedback for their exceptional printing quality, ensuring utmost customer satisfaction.
On the other hand, Customcat has faced criticism for its inconsistent printing, particularly in relation to white text.
High-quality products are crucial for building trust and attracting repeat customers, making Printify the preferred choice for those seeking superior craftsmanship.
Having products that meet customers’ expectations is paramount to the success of any eCommerce business.
Printify’s commitment to delivering superior craftsmanship ensures that you can confidently offer high-quality products to your customers, fostering loyalty and recurring business.
Check Out: Printify vs Gooten
Printify vs CustomCat – Print Coverage
When it comes to print coverage, Printify and CustomCat offer different options for fulfillment centers and print locations.
These factors can greatly impact shipping times, shipping costs, and the overall customer experience.
Let’s compare the print coverage of both platforms to determine which one suits your business needs.
Printify has established an extensive print network with fulfillment centers in multiple countries. This wide coverage includes:
| Print Locations | Shipping Times | Shipping Costs |
|---|---|---|
| USA | 1-7 business days | Varies based on location |
| Canada | 2-10 business days | Varies based on location |
| UK | 2-7 business days | Varies based on location |
| EU | 2-7 business days | Varies based on location |
| Australia | 3-10 business days | Varies based on location |
| China | 5-15 business days | Varies based on location |
Printify’s vast network of fulfillment centers ensures that your products can be produced, packed, and shipped efficiently from multiple locations around the world.
This leads to faster shipping times, lower shipping costs, and a reduced carbon footprint.
Unfortunately, CustomCat does not disclose specific information about their print locations. As a result, it is unclear where their fulfillment centers are located and the corresponding shipping times and costs.
Without this transparency, it becomes challenging to predict the speed and cost of shipping for your customers. This lack of information may also limit your ability to optimize your production and delivery strategies.
As you can see, Printify’s extensive print coverage gives it a clear advantage over CustomCat. The ability to ship from various locations ensures faster delivery, lower costs, and a more sustainable approach to printing and fulfillment.
Consider these factors when choosing a print-on-demand platform for your eCommerce business.
| Printify | CustomCat | |
|---|---|---|
| Print Locations | USA, Canada, UK, EU, Australia, China | Unknown |
| Shipping Times | 1-15 business days (varies by location) | Unknown |
| Shipping Costs | Varies by location | Unknown |
| Transparency | High | Low |
Also Read: Printify vs MyDesigns
Printify vs CustomCat – Product Selection
When it comes to product selection, Printify outshines Customcat with its extensive catalog and more branding options.
Printify offers over 850 products in various categories, including men’s, women’s, and kids’ clothing, accessories, home decor, shoes, pet supplies, and swimwear.
This wide range of choices allows sellers to cater to different customer preferences and target specific niche markets.
On the other hand, Customcat’s catalog is relatively limited, with only around 300 products available.
While it still covers some essential categories, the selection might not be as diverse as Printify’s, making it challenging to meet the specific demands of your target audience.
Moreover, Printify provides more branding options compared to Customcat. With Printify, sellers can take advantage of additional customization features like neck labels and package inserts.
These branding options allow for more personalized and unique touchpoints with customers, enhancing your brand’s visibility and customer loyalty.
Here is a comparison table illustrating the difference in product selection and branding options:
| Printify | Customcat | |
|---|---|---|
| Product Selection | Over 850 products | Approximately 300 products |
| Branding Options | Neck labels, package inserts | N/A |
Thebroader range of choices and customization opportunities can help you create a unique brand identity and stand out in the competitive eCommerce landscape.
Also Read: Printful vs CustomCat
Printify vs CustomCat – Sales Channel Integrations
When it comes to expanding your eCommerce business, having access to a wide range of sales channels is crucial.
Let’s compare their capabilities and see which platform provides better options for broadening your market reach.
Printify offers an impressive array of sales channel integrations, allowing you to seamlessly connect your store with popular platforms:
- Shopify
- Walmart
- SquareSpace
- Etsy
On the other hand, Customcat primarily focuses on integrating with Etsy, limiting your options for selling on various platforms.
The availability of multiple sales channel integrations provided by Printify gives you the opportunity to reach more potential customers across different online marketplaces, social media platforms, and your own website.
By connecting your store to platforms like Shopify, Walmart, SquareSpace, and Etsy, you can tap into a wider audience and maximize your sales potential.
Printify offers a more diverse range of sales channel integrations compared to Customcat.
If you’re looking to reach a larger audience and sell across different online marketplaces, Printify’s integrations with Shopify, Walmart, SquareSpace, and Etsy provide you with greater flexibility and potential sales opportunities.
Whether you’re just starting your eCommerce journey or looking to expand your existing business, having multiple sales channel integrations can significantly impact your visibility and success.
By choosing Printify, you can leverage the power of various platforms to attract more customers and increase your revenue.
Printify vs CustomCat – Profitability
Profitability is a crucial factor to consider when deciding between Printify and Customcat for your print-on-demand business.
By using a t-shirt sales profit calculator, you can assess the profit margins offered by each platform.
After conducting calculations, it becomes evident that Printify outperforms Customcat in terms of profit margins, making it the more profitable choice. Let’s take a closer look:
When selling 10 t-shirts at a price of $25 each, Printify can yield a monthly profit of $170. This number increases to $460 for 30 t-shirts and a substantial $1,670 for 100 t-shirts.
On the other hand, Customcat’s profit margins are comparatively lower. Selling 10 t-shirts at the same $25 price would result in a monthly profit of $150, whereas selling 30 t-shirts would generate $390, and selling 100 t-shirts would bring in $1,430.
By choosing Printify, you can maximize your profit margins and optimize the financial success of your t-shirt business.
Conclusion
With higher profit margins, superior quality, an extensive print network, a larger product selection, and more sales channel integrations, Printify offers a comprehensive package for eCommerce businesses.
Printify’s profit margins are notably higher compared to Customcat, providing sellers with greater revenue potential.
Independent reviewers have consistently praised Printify’s superior quality, while Customcat has faced some issues with inconsistent printing.
Additionally, Printify’s wide print network and multiple fulfillment centers in various countries lead to faster shipping times and lower shipping costs.
With over 850 products in its catalog and a variety of branding options, Printify offers sellers more flexibility and customization opportunities.
Furthermore, Printify surpasses Customcat in terms of sales channel integrations. With integrations with popular platforms like Shopify, Walmart, SquareSpace, and Etsy, Printify allows sellers to expand their market reach and increase their sales potential.
While Customcat primarily integrates with Etsy, Printify offers a wider range of options for eCommerce businesses.
While Printify emerges as the top choice overall, customcat may have certain unique features or advantages that align better with specific business requirements.
Therefore, it is recommended that sellers carefully evaluate their individual circumstances before making a final decision.
